Making a meth fuel cell Diff btwn 5051 and 5052?

Grimgrak

New member
I've noticed rci makes their cells out of 5051 but my local supplier only carries 5052 can anyone tell me the difference between the two alloys?
 

10secTy

Sy-Ty builder and Tuner
Re: Making a meth fuel cell Diff btwn 5051 and 5052?

use a plastic cell then zero issues.

Nolan
 

'JustDreamin'

Dream: 6LV8 Turbo Bravada
Re: Making a meth fuel cell Diff btwn 5051 and 5052?

5052 has a slightly higher Chromium content. Is slightly stronger in the same heat treat conditions (ie comparing 5051 H34 to 5052 H34, 5052 is slightly stronger).


I used to work in sheet metal, and most everything we did was 5052, because it is what is commercially available (from big distributors). Balance of our aluminum work was 6061, which you can't bend with a press brake (it fractures) unless you use big radius tools (like 1" radius bends for .090" sheet).

The gas tank in my boat is 5052, its a reasonablye good choice for marine environments.


HOWEVER, you shouldn't be building a methanol tank out of aluminum. Methanol and alum don't get along. It will eat it (not in a week, but it will eat throught it eventually, all the while putting crap in your alky system). Use a plastic tank out of a material approved for methanol.

'JustDreamin'
 

Grimgrak

New member
Re: Making a meth fuel cell Diff btwn 5051 and 5052?

Well that just really puts a damper on things, I'm trying to make a custom tank for max storage capacity as I want to do some run what you brung events. And if I just happen to bring a 10-15 gal tank it would surely cover any road race and drag race events.
10secTy said:
use a plastic cell then zero issues.

Nolan
 

'JustDreamin'

Dream: 6LV8 Turbo Bravada
Re: Making a meth fuel cell Diff btwn 5051 and 5052?

Grimgrak said:
Well that just really puts a damper on things, I'm trying to make a custom tank for max storage capacity as I want to do some run what you brung events. And if I just happen to bring a 10-15 gal tank it would surely cover any road race and drag race events.
IF this is for a race only vehicle, where you'd fill it, use it, and then be able to drain / rinse it, alum would be acceptable.....

OR, if you were to have the inside hard anodized, that should cure the problem too (verify the hard anodizing will stand up to methanol).

Alum oxidizes pretty readily and forms a layer of aluminum oxide that is fairly impervious to water (under most conditions) and keeps the aluminum underneath from corroding (unlike steel). But that layer of aluminum oxide is methanol soluble, so the protective layer gets dissolved exposing new aluminum to corrode.

Like I said, there are solutions to the problem if you really want to run a custom metal tank. But I might look at plastic tanks first to rule them out. Steel would also be an acceptable choice (methanol doesn't really have an effect on steel) but it might be heavier.

'JustDreamin'
 

JSM

Active member
Re: Making a meth fuel cell Diff btwn 5051 and 5052?

Or go stainless, again heavier but no corrosion and you could run fairly thin with some reinforments or beads in it.
 

Tooky

Serious about performance
Re: Making a meth fuel cell Diff btwn 5051 and 5052?

I've been wanting to upgrade my SMC alky to a much larger storage tank (1-5 gallons) but fabrication is my weakest skill. If anyone has any clever solutions for where/how to locate an alky tank on a stock-ish Syclone, I'd be grateful if you shared them.

The bed seems obvious but I was concerned about the time from turn on until it reaches the nozzle.
 

Grimgrak

New member
Re: Making a meth fuel cell Diff btwn 5051 and 5052?

The turn on is not really an issue because the line is already charged and filled tho if you store if over long periods the line could dry up. However you could of course mount a purge or manually purge it after long storage.
Tooky said:
I've been wanting to upgrade my SMC alky to a much larger storage tank (1-5 gallons) but fabrication is my weakest skill. If anyone has any clever solutions for where/how to locate an alky tank on a stock-ish Syclone, I'd be grateful if you shared them.

The bed seems obvious but I was concerned about the time from turn on until it reaches the nozzle.
 

Grimgrak

New member
Re: Making a meth fuel cell Diff btwn 5051 and 5052?

The guys at RCI seem to think that 5051 will be fine for methonal use. They say that guys run aluminum tanks all the time, and have never had any problems just dont use the foam as it eats away at it. However i'd like to play it safe. My main concern with SS is that I can't find any rules for nhra safety thickness. Does anyone have a rule book handy?
 

VIPERRACING

New member
Re: Making a meth fuel cell Diff btwn 5051 and 5052?

Only use plastic. Just use a plastic fuel cell. They come in many sizes. :tup:
 
Top