IC lines and Aux IC-line routing

junkydogg

New member
does anyone know how to setup the aux ic using the 3/4 heater hose lines instead of the stock metal ones. i need to know how to route all hoses.. thanks
 

Ian Turgeon

Cascading Inspiration
Heres a little background thinking.

The pump pushes better then it sucks (thats partially why its near the bottom of the system - gravity feed) So you dont want the pump to suck the water through the heat exchangers.

Stock:

Bottom of upper IC Into pump
Pump to passanger side of heat exchanger
Driver's side to top of upper IC.

I simply added the aux cooler after the stock heat exchanger, so the driver's side of the stock heat exchanger into my aux cooler, then to the upper IC.
 

InvisiBill

Active member
Daron and I debated this last time it came up... I ran my "cool" line from the heat exchanger to the bottom of the charge air cooler. As the coolant heats up from the hot intake air, it will naturally rise up and out the top, back to the CCHE.

However, if you are low on coolant (enough that it's not up to the top exit of the CAC), the coolant will basically just sit there and boil. Using the stock/Daron method, the cool coolant comes in from the top, and would simply fall down into the CAC if it weren't full, then out the bottom to the CCHE.

Ian: Isn't the pump always sucking in as much as it's pushing out? This confused me with fans on computer heatsinks too. With those, it came down to the fact that the pushed air was more turbulent, and caused more contact between the air and heatsink if the fan blew into it. Not trying to be a smartass, I just get confused by this stuff where it seems like it should be the same at either end.
 

Daron

Active member
What works very well for me is to route the hoses starting from the pump... Output of pump goes up the drivers side ( too many sharp turns when routed on the passengers side) and into the top port on the IC. The bottom port on the IC goes down the drivers side to top of your stock CCHE ( or to the top of your aux CCHE), then the lowest point of your CCHE goes to the intake of your pump.
This is how the stock system is and it uses gravity to enhance flow, doesnt fight against it by pushing up needlessly. If you want to test which works best, route your system and fill it with water, then run your pump. After you get all the air out you will find that you can fill a bucket faster this way.
 

InvisiBill

Active member
Check out "Fluid Basics" on page 42 of http://www.humboldt1.com/~michael.welch/olson85.pdf for more info on the gravity thing. It's actually discussing flow in solar panel heating systems, but the same laws of physics apply to our fluid-based heat transfer system.

The static head is equal to zero in a pressurized, closed loop system completely filled with fluid. Gravity is not a factor because the pressure is equal throughout the system. The amount of force (pressure) of the fluid above the discharge or outlet side of the pump is counterbalanced by the amount of force (pressure) of the fluid above the suction or inlet side of the pump; net static head is zero.

Like I was trying to explain before, the force of gravity pulling the fluid down in that part of the system is counteracted by the gravity acting on the fluid in the other half of the system (which is trying to move upwards).

I don't have any evidence of how the flow of the heat affects the performance of the IC system, but I can say that it's physically impossible for gravity to affect the flow of a full stock IC system.

It makes no difference if the coolant flows up through the rubber hose and down through the CAC, or up through the CAC and down through the hose. It still has to go up X distance and back down as far. Since it's a closed loop full of fluid, think of it like a piece of string tied in a loop. If you pull down on both sides equally, you get no net movement. Gravity is pulling down on both the up- and down-flowing sides of the IC system, so there is no net change in flow.

Edit: Me tipe gud.

<font size=-1>[ This Message was edited by: InvisiBill on 2002-01-03 00:05 ]</font>
 

Daron

Active member
For gravity not to be an issue, the fluid must be under pressure and the system must be completely filled with fluid.

When my cap is off the top of the CAC, the system is not pressurized. I can watch the fluid flow as it passes the opening. The only way my IC is going to be pressurized is if it gets hot, which occurs almost never and is contrary to my goals for the heat transfer fluid. I want it cold.
I can go down the 1/4, turn in the staging lanes and pop my CAC cap off without spillage. FWIW, I also have my overflow line capped. So, in my truck I'd want things flowing optimally under zero pressure conditions, as that is the desired state.

From your article: "A column of water 2.31 feet (0.7 m) high exerts a pressure of one pound per square inch (psi)."
The water exerts pressure because it weighs something. It has weight because of gravity.

So, if you want to run your IC hot enough that it has enough pressure built up in there for the "anti-gravity IC", go for it :wink:
 

JoeLutz

New member
Liquid water is considered incompressible. Air is very compressable/expandable meaning the same mass of air can fill many different volumes depending upon pressure and temp. Steam, like air is also compressible. IF you could possibly keep the IC system completely full of compressed liquid water all the time, the position of the pump wouldn't be much of an issue, however this is almost impossible due to the heating, cooling, and circulation of the coolant. If the pump is up high, the acceleration of gravity tries pulls the coolant away form both sides of the pump meaning any air that may get into the system will find its way into the pump. Due to the compressible/expandable nature of air, the pump will begin begin to cavitate as it tries to "suck" air. There is no such thing as absolute vaccum, just an absence of atmospheric pressure which is arround 14.7psi. A 'perfect' vaccum pump could never acheive a pressure difference on the intake side greater than this, because the limiting factor is atmospheric pressure. a coolant pump is a far cry from a 'perfect' vacum pump. It doesn't like to suck air. Have you ever heard of vapor lock in a fuel system? Its the same type of situation.

Now lets suppose that the sytem is free of air. Water boils at a given temp AND pressure. The lower the pressure, the lower the boiling temp. With our pump mounted high, the lowest pressure in the system is at the inlet of the pump. Say your water temp is not near to the boiling temp at atmospheric, it may still be boiling in the low pressure region at the inlet of the pump. What do we get when water boils? Steam. Steam, like air, is a compressible fluid. So we have the same type of situation. The pump cavitates and gets hot as it tries to pump steam.
So yes it does mater where the pump is located. Low as possible with the most amount of pressure on the inlet side is best.

just sharing some stuff I learned in thermodynamics.

_________________
93 Typhoon
67 VW Bug Judson SC
67 Chevy Stepside
68 Camaro RS/SS
88 Zuk
91 VW Corrado G60
communities.msn.com/joeelutz

<font size=-1>[ This Message was edited by: joeelutz on 2002-01-03 20:14 ]</font>
 

InvisiBill

Active member
If what you're saying is true, then all the coolant in the top of your IC system would constantly be falling down due to gravity. This would cause flow in the system even when the truck is off.

The coolant at the top doesn't fall down, because the gravitational forces are equal on the "up" hose. Since the fluid on both sides is being pushed down equally toward the CCHE (in opposite directions of flow), there is no net flow.

The system does not have to be pressurized for this to occur. You can make a level out of a long section of clear tubing. Fill it most of the way with water, and have one person at each end, holding it in a sort of U shape. No matter how high either person holds their end of the tubing, the equal gravitational forces at each end will push the water down until it's level. This makes the waterline at each end of the tube the same height.

You could do the same thing if you cut one of your IC hoses and held the ends up to make a U. According to you, all the coolant in the CAC would fall down the hose. However, gravity is pushing the coolant in the other hose down wiht the same force, so you get no net movement, and you'll get the same results as the tube-of-water level.
 

JoeLutz

New member
No you are misunderstanding what I am saying. First, gravity is an acceleration. Force is mass times acceleration (F=ma) according to Newton's first law. Weight is a force due to gravity. It is true that the water level doesn't fall due to the fact that there is a presence of water throughout the system, supporting the water at the surface and water is incompressible. The example of the hose held up in a U full of water is exactly right. The water level at both sides would be the same because gravity acts on the water through out the hose and therefore it is like a balance with equal weight on both sides. My point is when that system is in equilibrium with no flow such as with the U shaped hose, the highest pressure is at the bottom of the system or hose, because the water in the bottom is supporting the weight of the water above it. Therefore, the equilibrium water pressure increases with depth. Its the same principle that causes the high water pressure when diving. The deeper you go the higher the pressure.
So at the highest point, the water pressure in the hose is the lowest, being atmospheric due to the fact that there is no water above it pushing down on it, just air.
Also remember that any air that may find its way into the system will go to the highest point because air is much less dense than water hence it weighs less.

Its not a mater of how deep the system is or how much static equilibrium pressure is at the bottom of the system, what maters is that the pressure is the least at the highest point and greatest at the lowest point.

Remember that Force = mass x acceleration
Pressure = Force x area
Just because ther is pressure doesn't mean that there is flow. There is no flow when the pressure is in equilibrium such as in the case of the U shaped hose.
 

InvisiBill

Active member
joemama, I was responding to Daron, not you. I agree that the highest pressure in the system will be at the lowest point due to gravity, and that any air will be at the top. I was simply trying to explain why gravity won't help flow in a full, closed system like ours (pushing with the flow on the "down" side, but equally against flow on the "up" side).
 

Daron

Active member
He was pointing out why our system isnt "closed". I think that your assertions may have merit in a continually pressurized system, but my CAC doesnt normally get hot enough for this to be a concern. I want it flowing good when it is cool and at the same pressure as atomosphere (since that is the pressure in which I fill it).
 

smeagol

Active member
I spoke to someone at NASA, and he said you are all idiots and to go with air-air intercoolers

jk

:wink:
 

InvisiBill

Active member
BG, my friend at NASA said that you should go study Uranus. =)

Daron, the system does not have to be completely sealed off from the rest of the world for this to happen. If you had a bucket full of water being pumped down a hose, through a CAC, into another hose and bucket, yes it would flow faster due to gravity. However, if the bottom hose looped back up to the top bucket (i.e. no bottom bucket), then you would have equal forces pushing the upward flow backwards and the downward flow forward. The equal but opposite forces would cancel each other out and provide no net change in flow.

You can also think of a vertical hula hoop with a hole drilled in the upper wall at the top, completely filled with water. Even though it's open to the atmosphere (via the hole in the top) and thus at the same pressure, there are equal forces pushing down on the water in both sides. Water falling down on one side would have to push the water on the other side up to make room at the bottom, since water can not be compressed. To move that water up (with gravity pushing down on it), you'd need some external form of force in addition to the gravity pushing down equally on the other side, like a Jabsco.

If you have a gap (air bubble) between the water level in your CAC and the top hose entry, then yes, gravity would pull the incoming water down, and the lighter air up. Pumping the water up above the "balanced" water level of the system would create unbalance, and that water would flow downward to return the system to a balanced state again.

However, if your water level is above that entry point, which a full IC system should be, then there are equal but opposite gravitational forces on the two sides of the IC system, again causing no net flow.
 

JoeLutz

New member
BG, I think your friend at NASA should buy us all Air-air IC's.

I know my input is probably not welcome here, but the point I was trying to make is that if the pump is sucking air (or steam), it will not work very well. It is a moving boundary system, because the rubber lines among other things are flexible, so the total volume of the system can change. Water at low pressure can expand into steam at a lower temp than at high pressure. This could be the case at the inlet of a pump located at the top of the system where the pressure would be the lowest to begin with.

_________________
Joe Lutz
Steel lernin hoaw to speal
93 Typhoon
67 VW Bug Judson SC
67 Chevy Stepside
68 Camaro RS/SS
88 Zuk
91 VW Corrado G60
communities.msn.com/joeelutz

<font size=-1>[ This Message was edited by: joemama on 2002-01-08 20:21 ]</font>
 
G

Guest

Guest
Daron,

That pic is funny as hell :grin: I wonder if bdubb and brenda are going to get back together?


<font size=-1>[ This Message was edited by: ncsyclone0760 on 2002-01-08 20:56 ]</font>
 

Daron

Active member
I think BG is really on to something :wink: ...

From the web page you referenced before:

"The static head is equal to zero in a pressurized,
closed loop system completely filled with fluid. Gravity
is not a factor because the pressure is equal
throughout the system. The amount of force
(pressure) of the fluid
above the discharge or
outlet side of the pump is
counterbalanced by the
amount of force
(pressure) of the fluid
above the suction or inlet
side of the pump; net
static head is zero."

Our system is not necessarily a closed, pressurized system.

Your statement earlier
" I agree that the highest pressure in the system will be at the lowest point due to gravity, and that any air will be at the top. I was simply trying to explain why gravity won't help flow in a full, closed system like ours (pushing with the flow on the "down" side, but equally against flow on the "up" side)."

Since we have already aggreed that gravity affects the inlet side of our pump and that air bubbles will travel up ( they wouldnt do that in a system with equal pressure) other arguements are interesting but are not convincing. You cannot have gravity, then ignore it....

I am obviously not an expert in fluid dynamics, but have routed my CAC hoses various ways, and settled on the way that works best. I have mentioned before that you try different routing to verify your theories/ debunk mine, have you considered it?


_________________
Daron
1992 Typhoon Blue/Gray
1991 Syclone Best 1/4 12.42 @ 106.1
Member Of Freakin' Ohio (MOFO) SyTy
00011.jpg

http://www.geocities.com/brianaustingreenonline/



<font size=-1>[ This Message was edited by: Daron on 2002-01-09 09:19 ]</font>
 
Top