Is there bad dealing going on here?

Windedv6

Ty n 10s
There was post on here the last couple of days regarding GM 18* bowtie heads and a Daytona intake. The member/seller was asking $900 for the heads and $500 for the intake. The member/seller asked that a buyer also pay for shipping and the Paypal charges. I posted that I would take them both and to give me the total price including the PP charges and shipping to 46845. There was no mistake about my intentions to purchase these items.

The member's complete thread has been taken down including my post. If this done was to block a sell from a very legit purchaser then this is bad dealing. If it is a BB problem then the thread needs to be put back up.

I would like a explaination. Let's start with the board admins in the event that this thread disappearance is a problem with the BB and the thread was taken down in error. If such the case, then the member/seller and I can finish the transaction.

John
 
Last edited:

WyoSyclone

Active member
Re: Is there bad dealing going on here?

I saw that thread yesterday John.... I think you also asked if he was going to be selling that sheet aluminum intake.... kind of strange that the thread just disappeared.
 

Jimmy

Banned
Re: Is there bad dealing going on here?

Maybe Rick deleted the thread cause you bought them?
:dunno:
 

4C FED

Absolutum Dominium
Re: Is there bad dealing going on here?

WTF?! It wasn't me. I did not delete the thread. I only modified the title from FS to SOLD.
And I still have the intent of delivering those items to you as promised.
No shenanigans on my side. I'm just trying to find suitable boxes for everything.

John, PM me your shipping info, please.
 

Jimmy

Banned
Re: Is there bad dealing going on here?

WTF?! It wasn't me. I did not delete the thread. I only modified the title from FS to SOLD.
And I still have the intent of delivering those items to you as promised.
No shenanigans on my side. I'm just trying to find suitable boxes for everything.

John, PM me your shipping info, please.
Thread was deleted because it was sold.:2cents:

Just keeping the forum clean.
 

4C FED

Absolutum Dominium
Re: Is there bad dealing going on here?

Thread was deleted because it was sold.:2cents:

Just keeping the forum clean.

It's kinda nice though to have something to reference back to for other peeps who might be looking to buy/sell for pricing purposes.
 

Windedv6

Ty n 10s
Re: Is there bad dealing going on here?

Thread was deleted because it was sold.:2cents:

Just keeping the forum clean.

It would also be nice to have the thread around long enough to not have to post a question like I did to about a potential problem. The last thing we need to do on this board is create bad vibs about long time solid members.

Rick, I will send PM.

John
 

Captain Morgan

Moderated User
Re: Is there bad dealing going on here?

Yes, I removed the thread once it was marked SOLD by the seller.

Apparently there were still things to be worked out :dunno: I wasnt aware, it was marked as sold, that usually means money has been exchanged and its good to go.

It would also be nice to have the thread around long enough to not have to post a question like I did to about a potential problem. The last thing we need to do on this board is create bad vibs about long time solid members.

Rick, I will send PM.

John
We've been removing "sold" threads for YEARS now as soon as they are spoted, nobody has had an issue with it before :dunno:

Ill put the thread back now if it helps.
 

4C FED

Absolutum Dominium
Re: Is there bad dealing going on here?

Yes, I removed the thread once it was marked SOLD by the seller.

Apparently there were still things to be worked out :dunno: I wasnt aware, it was marked as sold, that usually means money has been exchanged and its good to go.


We've been removing "sold" threads for YEARS now as soon as they are spoted, nobody has had an issue with it before :dunno:

Ill put the thread back now if it helps.

No problem.
I marked it sold because John has a good rep., so I knew it was a done deal.
 

Captain Morgan

Moderated User
Re: Is there bad dealing going on here?

No problem.
I marked it sold because John has a good rep., so I knew it was a done deal.

I understand, I had just assumed all the details had been worked out and the thread was just extra clutter. Usually Im not the one removing the threads, I just happened to see it while I was on, it wasn't intended to create drama. :D

When we post seller/buyer feedback, we have the option to link to the pertinent transaction thread. Deleting the sold threads would, because all transactions entail a 'sold' status, result in all these links being in-valid or 'broken'. So why have the reference?
because its included in the hack that was installed and its not worth digging through all the code to remove it.

I agree with Rick's assessment that it is nice to have the archive of 'solds' to use for price research. Particularly with the complete trucks.

I don't buy a lot of parts on the board, so I haven't been affected by this directly, but I have tried to conduct vehicle price assessments, and there isn't much in the way of off-market follow up. The selling price is seldom disclosed, which I feel is a shame, and detrimental to the hobby.

In the interest of conserving memory space, perhaps pruning the non-pertinent posts, and archiving the sold thread might serve those that are conducting pricing research?

:2cents:
Dave
Valid argument and I understand your points.

The researching sold prices is somewhat valid, however i have noticed that a good number of members when editing their thread to "sold status" usually deletes their asking price or many times delete their whole initial description and replaces it with the word sold, basically making the whole thread pointless to keep around. From the removed threads I have bothered to look at, Id say only 35% are useful for anything after the fact, but that is better than nothing I suppose.

I wish we could enforce a rule to have people not remove that information, but being that we still cant get people to post in the correct forums, I think the forum staff would be perceived as "mean guys" :lol: for making yet another rule thats just gonna get broken anyway.

As for the space issue, it was done primarily to speed up searches for users on here, not only with the speed of the database, but instead of having 15 threads of previously sold items pop up, it would only yield those items that were still available.

Perhaps a compromise can be made? Perhaps Ill create an "Sales Archive" forum which will be locked like the Vault, and any threads that actually have decent sales/pricing information in it will be saved. Threads which are determined "useless" and ALL threads pruned from the eBay/Internet Finds forum will continue to go in the trash as usual. :tup:
 

Windedv6

Ty n 10s
Re: Is there bad dealing going on here?

Perhaps a compromise can be made? Perhaps Ill create an "Sales Archive" forum which will be locked like the Vault, and any threads that actually have decent sales/pricing information in it will be saved. Threads which are determined "useless" and ALL threads pruned from the eBay/Internet Finds forum will continue to go in the trash as usual. :tup:

I research a lot of price comparisons on the board and is useful to search past threads to understand what others have sold items for. It may help keep some of the remarks to that hit a seller when they over price something. How many times do we see something for sale and someone else posts that someone 'recently sold one like it for less' or 'someone else's was in better condition'. It would best if we could search for like type sales an get our ads priced correctly.

It would also help those who are planning upgrades or needing parts in the future. To be able to go back and fine ads and pricing could help them plan ahead. Some BBs are setup with a defined sale template. Keeps the info consistent and the files clean, in order and easy to research. These setups also keep the sales transparant and cut down on any potential conflicts.

I have used the S10 Forum classified ad section. It is a great way to do it in my opinion. Easy to place an ad, keeps everything consistent, easy for seller and buyers to communicate, easy to search for parts or history, etc.

John
 
Last edited:

Norm

Donating Member
Re: Is there bad dealing going on here?

Interesting post and replies. I always like to see what stuff is "sold for" as compared to asking price. My biggest beef in a wanted section would be a buyer asking for a part and a person replying "p.m. send". Any future buyers would have no clue as to what a part might be worth. The same on the flip side. A person can put a part up for xxx amount of dollars and it won't sell. He could guess as to what he thinks it is worth and be totally out in left field, or he can ask yyy amount of dollars and have 20 people want to buy it because it was way too cheap of a price.
 

blk00z28

Forced to by choice
Re: Is there bad dealing going on here?

One of the other boards I was on at one point had it set to where you could not edit anything in the sale thread. Meaning you would need a mod to do it for you, both the main sale post or a reply to it. That might help?

Only problem I see with it though is your going to have A LOT of spelling errors, or linking problems, or just overall bullshit that I'm sure no one would want to go through every few hours. But thank god our sale area isn't huge and we dont have 350k members.

I like, and dislike old sale threads. I only say that because if I list a part, and no one touchs it. I edit the dollar amount. It could sit for 2-3 weeks and the price has dropped from the 'normal' price down to a hell of a deal just because its sat for a while and the seller would like it gone, but no ones in the market for that part now. This is going to cause a decline in prices for future sellers hoping to sell the same part. And not using 'the economy is bad' as the excuse. (look at stock exhaust manifolds, upper and lower intakes. I remember when exhaust sets even with cracks wouldn't come close to selling at $275.. Now avg is around there. And people blame the economy, no. People are just cheap and want a better deal then what's been offered before.) Which in that case the prices can be hidden I think.

But at a buyers view, let the prices keep falling! Lol.
 
Top